Upward motion of condensed water droplets in still air Upward motion of water droplets when not supported by convection currents has been observed (Piyadasa, 2012),
Why do clouds float in mid-air?
Do classical/conventional definitions provide answers?
In meteorology, a cloud is a visible mass of liquid water droplets or frozen crystals. Water is nearly 1000 times denser than air. If so, why does water float in mid-air?
- Clouds are floating even though it contains condensed water-droplets (Ho et al., 2003) which are 899 times denser than the surrounding air at the altitude 1,000 m and at temperature 8.5°C
- The ratio density of water to air becomes 1,667 times at altitude of 7,000 m 1,2 where temperature is around -40°C
- Distance between any two droplets is in the range of ≈1 mm and cloud water droplets keep this cumulative structure throughout the entire cloud, neither collapsing/attracting nor dispersing/repulsing each other.
On the above facts, it is common to see discussions on why clouds are floating in mid-air. There are no discussions on the cumulative structure (neither collapsing/attracting nor dispersing/repulsing property).
According to the present knowledge of science, there are only two possibilities for clouds to float in mid-air:
- Updraft that keep water droplets afloat (see the animation below).
1) Buoyancy (Liu et al., 2013) – All fluids (liquid or gas), in the presence of Earth’s gravity, exert an upward force known as the buoyant force on any other substance. Therefore, any substance with lower density would float or rise through a higher density fluid.
The mean average distance among droplets is around 1,000 µm (1 mm) and average droplet diameter (Volume Mean Diameter (VMD)) is ≈10 µm (Igel and van den Heever, 2017). Considering the distance among droplets to their size, there can only be gravitational and electromagnetics forces. Net charge of a cloud in fair weather condition is considered as zero (Allee and Phillips, 1959) and therefore electromagnetic forces among cloud water droplets are negligible. Therefore, droplets in a cloud are independent objects (water entities) in air
- Physics fact book https://hypertextbook.com/facts/2007/AllenMa.shtml
- The Engineering tool box https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/standard-atmosphere-d_604.html
(appearing as a cloud). Considering the density ratio, no buoyancy can be expected to support water droplets afloat in mid-air.
2) Updraft – The main argument in cloud physics is that fall of cloud droplets (Day, 2005) (Williams, 1997, Wang, 2013) towards the Earth is counteracted only by updraft (convection currents). See the animated Video 1 below. It is also worth mentioning that there exists a down draft similar to updraft in clouds (Tonttila et al., 2011) (Schmidt et al., 2012).
When the air is too cold to hold all its moisture, mist and fog usually form on a calm night. Volume Mean Diameter (VMD) of fog droplets are observed up to about 65µm (Kumai, 1973) (Lenham and Clay, 1982). In mist the VMD tends to be a little higher than in fog. In other words, mist is heavier and lies closer to the ground. The separation among these droplets is relatively large compared to their size. The number density of these droplets is around 25 droplets per cubic centimeter (Kumai, 1973). Mist and fog, hence, have similar composition as clouds.
Mist and fog form close to the ground level in still (or undisturbed) air where updraft (convection currents) do not exist. This is further observable in still or in slowly moving clouds early in the morning, in high mountains (Video 2) where the ground is cold (in some cases nearly frozen); thus no convection or updraft exists. This implies that updraft is not the cause to hold water droplets in mid-air.
In addition to that, it has been proven (Piyadasa, 2019) that, even if updraft does exist inside a cloud, it is not possible to maintain the water droplets afloat in mid-air by energy (momentum) transfer from air molecules to water droplets – the only fundamental mechanism in energy transfer in classical mechanics. Consider the facts:
Mass of a 10 μm water droplet = 5 × 10-6 kg
Mass of an average air molecule = 4.8 × 10-26 kg
Mass of a 10 μm water droplet is, hence, 1020 times greater than average mass of an air molecule. It is thus clear that according to ‘Newton’s Third Law’ momentum (energy) transfer from air molecules to water droplets collision is impossible in quantities sufficient to prevent the fall of cloud droplets. In this collision, according to classical mechanics, hardly any kinetic energy/momentum is transferred to water droplets from air molecules (calculation in  Appendix B).
Video 1: Animation of the classical concept of floating water droplets in mid-air due to updraft (convection currents)
The floating water droplets in mid air much clearer when considering following two examples.
- Moving clouds moving close to the ground in hill country
- Fog and mist, that also called ground level clouds
The natural phenomena, moving clouds moving close to the ground in hill country, Fog and mist, that also called ground level clouds, are also consists of water droplets and the density is 1000 times larger than surrounding air. Those water droplets in Fog and Mist are also floating in midair!
Video 2: Clouds float in mid air without any updraft, close to the ground in hill country
Figure 1. Fog and Mist. Ground level clouds are easily observable to exist with no updraft
The above discussed experimentally verified observations cannot be explained by existing theories! Nevertheless, these observations can easily be explained by assuming a gravitational repulsion force in addition to the gravitational attraction force.
What causes gravitational repulsion?
As gravitational attraction is caused by the mass, the gravitational repulsion is caused by the thermal energy. Please see Figure 2.
Above observations of the Nature simply tell us that there is a cryptic force, which acts as a repulsive force against the direction of the gravitational pull (i.e., a repulsive force between the Earth and water droplets in clouds).
- ALLEE, P A & PHILLIPS, B B 1959. MEASUREMENTS OF CLOUD-DROPLET CHARGE, ELECTRIC FIELD, AND POLAR CONDUCTIVITIES IN SUPERCOOLED CLOUDS. Journal of Atmospheric Sciences, 16, 405-410.
- HO, S -P, LIN, B, MINNIS, P & FAN, T -F. 2003. Estimates of cloud vertical structure and water amount over tropical oceans using VIRS and TMI data. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres,108
- IGEL, A L & VAN DEN HEEVER, S C 2017. The Importance of the Shape of Cloud Droplet Size Distributions in Shallow Cumulus Clouds. Part I: Bin Microphysics Simulations. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 74, 249-258.
- KUMAI, M. 1973. Arctic Fog Droplet Size Distribution and Its Effect on Light Attenuation. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 30, 635-643.
- LENHAM, A P & CLAY, M R 1982. Drop-size distribution of fog droplets determined from transmission measurements in the 0.53–10.1-μm wavelength range. Applied Optics, 21, 4191-4193.
- LIU, C, RANALD, G & EVETT, J 2013. Schaum’s Outline of Fluid Mechanics and Hydraulics, 4th Edition, McGraw-Hill Education.
- PIYADASA, C K G 2019. Antigravity, a major phenomenon in nature yet to be recognized. Physics Essays, 32, 10.
- SCHMIDT, K, HAGEN, M, HÖLLER, H, RICHARD, E & VOLKERT, H. 2012. Detailed flow, hydrometeor and lightning characteristics of an isolated thunderstorm during COPS. Atmos. Chem. Phys., 12, 6679-6698.
- TONTTILA, J, O’CONNOR, E J, NIEMELÄ, S, RÄISÄNEN, P & JÄRVINEN, H. 2011. Cloud base vertical velocity statistics: a comparison between an atmospheric mesoscale model and remote sensing observations. Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 9207-9218.